CATS CRADLE: WITCHMARK

By

Author: Andrew Hunt

Originally published: June 1992

Read: May-October 2026

Context: the whole idea of this blog was about books, with a new collection of VNA, PDA’S, EDA’s built etc etc I commited to read them all, a potentially un-doable challenge. It all started well however I ended up loosing the collector bug for books, sold them…started reading them as e-books and slowed significantly. At the same time I got back into Big Finish in a big way (pun intended). So I lost the rythm/habit of daily reading…chipping away week after week, trying to get to 10-12 reads a year. So, that has not really happened…however the green shoots of the habit have started to appear again and I managed to re-engage and get some books finished, this final part of the ‘cats cradle’ arc being the first…so, fingers crossed these book reviews become a little more frequent.

THE REVIEW

What I thought: This is a funny one, I did enjoy the first installement of the trilogy, and Warhead had momemts I enjoyed a lot, brutal though it was. The whole notion of a ‘trilogy’ was pretty vague at best (apart from a silvery weird cat in the TARDIS turning up) but I was expecting this final installment to make it all come together….and unless I missed some crucial pages this book does not do that, almost none the wiser after reading it to be honest. The start is good, weird goings on with mystical creatures in a remore welsh valley, some american students, some stereotyped welsh folks, then the seventh Doctor and Ace turning up, trying to work out whats going on. So far so good/standard, then we have the stone circle which ends up being a portal to a mystical realm, I was still with it at this point…but then it goes downhill for me. The different areas/species in this place make no sense, they have completly unproucebale names and their motives are vague/unknown…apart from the sun has died/is collapsing?

I know I never read this one as a teenager when the book first came out and I think I know why, this trilogy just lost me, and 30 odd years later I understand more of it, but i can see why these three books put me off as a kid. Quite a leap in quality at times, not as coherant as the Timewyrm books, an arc that isnt really an arc at all…it just doesnt work that well.

Still, I got some good things out of this, Ace gets lots to do and her character shines at times, and the 7th Doctor is good in this as well, a very clear character in his own right, mysterious and melacholic, an incarnation like no other. I like that. The story could have made a bit more sense though.

What I felt? Brutally confused at times and I was willing the book to end. There are moments I enjoyed but the parts are better than the whole in my opnion. Shame, but I know that

Rating: 2 out of 5 Unicorn horns: one I wont be returning to anytime soon.

What am I left thinking?

  • I am very hopeful that the next book, Nightshade, steps up the quality for these earliest new adventures.

Memorable bits

  • Ace riding a unicorn
  • The Doctor in the court of the fairy (possibly?) king
  • The TARDIS coming back together at the end of the book
Posted In ,

Leave a Reply